The gap between 71.8% saying they'd revise their views and 24.6% scoring low on overconfidence is the whole study in two numbers. It also explains why most client feedback sessions go fine and still change nothing.
And when you do check it, one of two things tends to happen: it survives on its own merits, or it comes apart without a fight. Your finding that “Claiming to be more humble than others predicts being less so” is the uncomfortable one. Did the scenarios show whether pausing before you react helps as much when the view being challenged is about yourself rather than about the work?
The identity cost seems bigger than the social one, because even changing your mind in private can feel like losing a piece of who you thought you were. I'd be curious whether the people who scored high on separating ego from intellect also have somewhere else their sense of worth comes from, since an idea is a lot easier to give up when it isn't the foundation of your whole sense of self.
The gap between 71.8% saying they'd revise their views and 24.6% scoring low on overconfidence is the whole study in two numbers. It also explains why most client feedback sessions go fine and still change nothing.
And when you do check it, one of two things tends to happen: it survives on its own merits, or it comes apart without a fight. Your finding that “Claiming to be more humble than others predicts being less so” is the uncomfortable one. Did the scenarios show whether pausing before you react helps as much when the view being challenged is about yourself rather than about the work?
The identity cost seems bigger than the social one, because even changing your mind in private can feel like losing a piece of who you thought you were. I'd be curious whether the people who scored high on separating ego from intellect also have somewhere else their sense of worth comes from, since an idea is a lot easier to give up when it isn't the foundation of your whole sense of self.